The November elections have come and gone. Campaign signs linger in a few yards, as they tend to do. The votes are tallied, and candidates and their supporters are left to consider the outcome. Some are pleased, others less so. Beyond the usual tally of winners and losers, the growing divisiveness of our elections seems to have taken on a life of its own.
Even in local races, where candidates and voters are often neighbors or colleagues, political disagreements have a way of becoming personal. A difference of opinion can be mistaken for a test of loyalty. Support for one candidate is read as opposition to another, and relationships that predate the campaign sometimes find themselves under new strain.
It is curious how elections, even at the local level, have acquired such consequence that they sometimes resemble low-intensity civil wars rather than contests of competing ideas. Perhaps the explanation is not simply how we treat one another, but the amount of authority we’ve entrusted to government.
The Establishment Has Abandoned Conservative Principles
Somewhere along the way, the establishment seems to have misplaced the meaning of conservatism. These days, to call oneself a conservative is often to specify fiscal or social leanings. The terms have become identities in their own right, useful for sorting candidates and policies into familiar categories. They also serve as shorthand to attract the right audience. What they do not necessarily reflect is a commitment to the foundational principles of American government.
Fiscal conservatism emphasizes spending, taxation, and debt. Social conservatism is more concerned with preserving traditional values. Both have their place, but neither, on its own, amounts to a commitment to constitutionalism, republicanism, or federalism. It is not uncommon to find someone advocating for reduced government spending while supporting powers the Constitution never delegated. Others may wish to preserve traditional values by using the government to impose those preferences, regardless of constitutional limits. In both cases, the question shifts from whether government has any authority to act to whether it is producing the desired result.
This has resulted in the term conservative being borrowed by various interests, each eager to advance its own objectives, sometimes at the expense of limited government. This form of “Konservatism” is less about restraining government than about directing it toward particular ends. Constitutionalism, republicanism, and federalism are not simply policy preferences. They are structural principles, meant to define and restrain political power, regardless of whoever happens to hold it. If those principles are set aside whenever they prove inconvenient, it is difficult to say what, if anything, is being conserved.
A System Designed to Limit Power
The constitutional system was never premised on the idea that Americans would agree. The Founders understood that people have competing interests and would disagree about religion, economics, morality, property, and the proper arrangement of society. That the Northern and Southern states managed to form a national government at all was something of a marvel. Rather than expecting those differences to vanish, they built a framework in which disagreement could persist without granting one faction unlimited authority over another.
James Madison acknowledged this reality in Federalist No. 10, recognizing that political factions were an inevitable consequence of human nature. As Madison explained:
“The inference to which we are brought is, that the causes of faction cannot be removed, and that relief is only to be sought in the means of controlling its effects.”
His solution was not to eliminate competing interests or to insist on universal agreement, but to establish a framework that prevents political factions, even those commanding a majority, from using government power to infringe upon others’ rights.
Constitutionalism made government subject to law. Republicanism placed authority in the hands of representatives accountable to the people, while limiting the hazards of direct democracy. Federalism divided power between the national government and the states, and the separation of powers distributed federal authority among three branches.
The Founders disagreed, sometimes vigorously, about the proper reach of government. Still, their framework reflected a basic recognition: concentrated political power invites abuse, no matter who holds it. Thomas Jefferson captured this concern in his draft of the Kentucky Resolutions of 1798, declaring:
“In questions of power then let no more be heard of confidence in man, but bind him down from mischief by the chains of the Constitution.”
The goal was never to guarantee that only the virtuous would hold office. It was to build institutions capable of restraining the ambitions and excesses of those who were not. Federalism further allowed states to pursue different approaches, learning from one another’s successes and failures without imposing a single answer upon the entire country.
When we set aside these limitations, the consequences reach well beyond constitutional theory. The more decisions government assumes, the more consequential its control becomes. Elections cease to be merely contests of ideas and increasingly become struggles over who gets to exercise that authority.
When Control of Government Becomes the Prize
Over time, the role of government has expanded considerably. Decisions once left to individuals, families, businesses, or local communities now often fall under the influence of regulations, agencies, and national politics. Some of this expansion has addressed genuine problems. Other times, emergencies, economic circumstances, or the promise of better outcomes have provided the rationale. Whatever the justification, each new responsibility assumed by government becomes another question settled through political power. The more authority government accumulates, the more valuable it becomes to those who would control it.
Consider two communities with different priorities and beliefs. Under a system that respects local decision-making, each can pursue its own approach. Neither must prevail over the other. But when decisions are transferred to a central authority, the question becomes which approach will be imposed upon both. What was once a disagreement between communities becomes a struggle for political control. We lose opportunities for people with different beliefs to coexist under different policies, while increasing the number of disputes that must be settled through centralized power.
Under genuinely limited government, losing an election may mean little more than disagreeing with the priorities of those in office. Constitutional restraints protect certain areas of individual life and prevent the winners from exercising authority they do not possess. As those restraints weaken, however, losing can begin to feel less like a temporary setback and more like a threat to one’s way of life.
The consequences are predictable. Political opponents become adversaries to be defeated at almost any cost. Elected officials find reasons to stretch their authority, particularly when convinced their successors will do likewise. Each side invokes the other’s conduct, and every new exercise of authority becomes a precedent for the next. When neither side reins in the power of government, the side in control will wield it.
When nearly everything becomes a political question, nearly every disagreement becomes a political battle. And when losing feels intolerable, compromise begins to look like surrender. The business of limiting government has given way to the business of controlling it.
The Problem With Political Compromise
Calls for civility, cooperation, and compromise are not in short supply. Yet the architecture of our political system has made those objectives increasingly difficult to achieve. Disagreements over matters beyond the government’s reach tend to remain just that—disagreements. People can disagree without necessarily requiring one side to surrender its freedom of choice. When government takes up the authority to decide for everyone, however, the same dispute becomes a contest with higher stakes. Compromise, unsurprisingly, grows more elusive.
None of this is to say that compromise is without value, or that government should never act. Some problems do require collective effort. Still, political cooperation is not a stand-in for constitutional boundaries. Civility, admirable as it is, cannot be expected to resolve every conflict that arises when more decisions are drawn into the political sphere.
Occasionally, the solution to a political dispute is not a compromise at all, but a recognition that the question may not belong to government. In other cases, the wiser course might be to return the matter to a state, a community, or even an individual who is closer to the facts.
The Responsibility of the People
It is tempting to assign all fault to politicians. Yet elected officials, for better or worse, tend to reflect the expectations of those who put them in office.
We are quick to criticize government overreach, except when intervention serves our own interests. Abuses of authority by opponents are condemned while similar conduct by allies is rationalized. Constitutional limits are essential when the other side is in charge, but often seem negotiable when our own candidates prevail.
A constitutional limit that applies only when it suits us is not much of a limit. The real measure of our commitment to limited government is our willingness to restrain those with whom we agree. An election victory, after all, is not a blank check.
###
Behind Every Blade of Grass
There’s a running joke around our office that Citizens for a New Louisiana is hiding behind every blade of grass. We’ve heard stories about government officials reconsidering questionable decisions because they were worried we’d find out. That’s a remarkable return on an investment we never made: "reaping where we did not sow, and gathering where we scattered no seed." But there’s something important in here, too.
Our little flashlight has earned us a reputation for bringing things to light. Now many officials act as if someone is watching, even when there isn't. That’s the real value of our government transparency work. It's more than just exposing wrongdoing after the fact. We've created an environment where public officials think twice.
Of course, we can’t actually be behind every blade of grass. There are thousands of public meetings, countless government transactions, and more questionable decisions than our small team could ever hope to investigate. But with your help, we can keep them wondering.
If you believe government works better when someone is paying attention, please consider supporting our work.
Become a Monthly MemberContribute $10 NowMake a Tax Deductible Gift
Already have a donor-advised fund? Ask your DAF administrator about recommending a grant to New Louisiana Foundation.

